Top Pizza Places in Flagstaff

Dive into decadent sauces and freshly baked pies of Flagstaff pizza restaurants. Enjoy a dine-in experience or order your food for the road. Whether you’re looking for dining spots downtown or seeking a quick bite after an action-packed day, these Flagstaff pizza places offer a wide range of savory pies for all palates.

Beaver Street Brewery

11 S Beaver Street #1, Flagstaff, AZ 86001

Looking to explore a piece of Flagstaff’s history with a slice of pizza? Visit the City of Seven Wonders’ first brew pub, which has been operating for almost two decades. Located just a block away from Flagstaff’s historic train station, Beaver Street Brewery is locally acclaimed for hearty pub food and a wide selection of beers. This bar and dining spot offers a variety of wood-fired pizzas with gluten-free and vegan options. Choose from an appetizing savory pie selection, including BBQ chicken, prosciutto pear, six cheeses, and more. 

Elevated Pizza Company

4650 N, US-89, Flagstaff, AZ 86004

Discover generous portions of toppings and sauces on bread that’s baked to a golden perfection. Elevated Pizza Company specializes in New York-style pizza and a variety of classic Italian eats. Taking a break from shopping? Based in Flagstaff Mall, this pizza place features a selection of savory pies with toppings such as mozzarella, bacon, sausage, and peppers. Complete your lunch or dinner with savory sides featuring garlic knots, toasted ravioli, and fried zucchini. For foodies with a sweet tooth, try a slice of cookie pie or housemade tiramisu for dessert. 

Fat Olives 

2308 E Route 66, Flagstaff, AZ 86004

Seeking ways to finish a day of exciting activities? This authentic Italian restaurant is just a seven-minute drive from Historic Downtown Flagstaff, a vibrant hub for a variety of things to do. Dive into Flagstaff’s thriving culinary scene with traditional ingredients such as ricotta, fennel sausages, and flour that’s imported from Italy. This Neapolitan-certified pizza place was featured on the Food Network with Guy Fieri enjoying the Kennai and Belgio Dolce pizzas. Travel across the different regions of Italy in Flagstaff with bruschetta boards, pasta, traditionally made pizzas, and creamy desserts.

Fratelli Pizza

2120 N 4th Street, Flagstaff, AZ 86004

Make your way to retro interiors, delectable bites, rich textures, and mouth watering pizza creations. Browse through a vast offering of pizzas, ranging from traditional to Chicago-style pies. Cultivate a customizable pizza experience with an assortment of sauces and toppings, or relish a specialty pie with ingenious combinations. Fratelli Pizza offers three locations across Flagstaff with seamless access to a wide range of exciting activities. Outdoor enthusiasts will enjoy a short drive from Bushmaster Park to this pizza place, ending a day of hiking and exploration with a slice of a savory pie. 

Lumberjack Pizza

104 E Route 66, Flagstaff AZ 86001

Be immersed in a lively atmosphere with decadent pizzas and friendly services. Located on the iconic Route 66, Lumberjack Pizza features a blend of modern and industrial decor with a flat screen T.V. for watching sports games. Indulge in classic pizzas or build your own savory pie with an assortment of heaping toppings. Watch your favorite sports and enjoy a slice of Hawaiian or a Meat Lover’s pizza. Lumberjack Pizza offers white pie options with cheese-centered combinations, including parmesan, ricotta, feta, and mozzarella. 

New Jersey Pizza Company

2224 E Cedar Avenue #6, Flagstaff, AZ 86004

Explore artisan-made pizza with a variety of succulent toppings for every pie lover. With a mountainous backdrop, this cozy eatery is a scenic spot for date nights, family-friendly gatherings, and group hangouts. Discover specialty pies such as the DiBartolo, which is topped with roasted tomatoes and melted mozzarella, or the Steamy “V,” which is a vegan-friendly pie with pineapple and fresh vegetables. For a customizable experience, cultivate the ultimate pizza topping combinations with items such as meatballs, jalapeños, and roasted garlic.

NiMarco’s Pizza

101 S Beaver Street, Flagstaff, AZ 86001

Visitors in downtown Flagstaff will enjoy this dog-friendly pizzeria with a laid back ambience. Nimarco’s Pizza creates each savory pie with an expertise over the crusts, baking crispy, airy, and flavorsome bread. Planning a kid-friendly outing? After traveling to the Lowell Observatory or Thorpe Park, take a quick drive to this casual pizzeria, welcoming pizza lovers of all ages. For foodies with a high spice tolerance, try the South of the Border pizza with a fiery combination of green chile sauce and jalapeños. Nimarco’s Pizza features an array of specialty pies including Popeye, Monster Meat, and Very Veggie.

Pizzicletta

203 W Phoenix Avenue, Flagstaff, AZ 86001

For an intimate dining experience, pedal your way to Pizzicletta, where the owner’s passion for pizzas and bicycles creates decadent meals. Browse through savory menu items featuring Margherita and marinara pizzas, or indulge in a sweet pizza with honey and mascarpone. Ice cream lovers will enjoy trying a tasting flight of gelato. Looking to pair your pizza with craft beer? Head over to Dark Sky Brewing and devour your savory slices with a refreshing IPA.

Taverna Modern

2420 S Woodlands Village Boulevard, Flagstaff, AZ 86001

Enter upscale and chic surroundings with customizable pizza offerings and traditional Mediterranean food. Build your own savory pie with different cheeses, vegetables, sauces, and your choice of protein. Taverna Modern serves the decadent Margherita and 3 Little Pigs pizzas, where ingredients such as calabrese, drizzled olive oil, and basil create harmonious flavors. Order delectable bites such as Moroccan wings, bacon dates, and breaded calamari. Find a sweet drink with your meal, discovering an array of cocktails, beer, and wine. 

The Pizza Guy

1417 S Plaza Way, Flagstaff, AZ 86001

Dive into New York-style pizza with thin crusts and flavorful kicks. The Pizza Guy offers classic savory pies that are reminiscent of Brooklyn eateries. Don’t miss trying this pizza spot’s traditional chicken wings with options for teriyaki, BBQ, and spicy sauces. Why not make a day of it? Embark on an 11-minute stroll to the Riordan Mansion State Historic Park and explore Flagstaff’s past. 

The Pizza Patio

109 E Phoenix Avenue, Flagstaff, AZ 86001

For a vegan lunch or dinner outing, the Pizza Patio features a wide variety of dairy- and meat-free specialties, ranging from Margherita and Hawaiian to Buffalo “chicken” and “pepperoni.” Luckily, this pizza place includes meat versions of the specialty pizzas, too. Pie lovers can build their own pizza with different types of baking styles, crusts, cheeses, and protein. With a relaxed environment and plenty of beers on tap, it’s easy to settle in and enjoy the tomato-infused cheesiness of a slice.

With chic dining spots, casual eateries, and Food Network-famous restaurants, Flagstaff’s burgeoning pizza scene is a history in the “baking.”

Looking for more? For the die-hard pizza fanatics, revisit familiar slices from Domino’s Pizza, Grimaldi’s Pizzeria, Little Caesars Pizza, Oregano’ Pizza Bistro, Papa John’s Pizza, Papa Murphy’s Take ‘N Bake Pizza, Peter Piper Pizza, and Your Pie Pizza.