Italian Dining Spots in Flagstaff

Whether you’re looking for family-friendly places to eat or seeking a fine dining experience for a special occasion, our list features some of the best Italian restaurants in Flagstaff. Find the ultimate foodie’s destinations across the City of Seven Wonders and discover what makes these eateries “pasta-tively” unforgettable.

Teatro Italian Food & Wine

16 N San Francisco Street

Explore authentic Italian food with risotto, gnocchi, tiramisu, and more. Teatro Italian Food and Wine serves scrumptious meals in a spacious area, where a dish like Antipasto Italiano can be enjoyed in a stylish setting. With handcrafted pasta and meats that are cooked to a golden texture, this restaurant will have you traveling to the eateries of Northern Italy without a plane ticket. Browse through a selection of more than 120 wines, relishing full-bodied and aromatic sips of flavor. 

Must-Have Dish: Try the Risotto Agli Asparagi, enjoying the savory and sweet combination of arborio rice, pear, mozzarella, and asparagus. 

Atria

103 N Leroux Street

Make your way to an airy space with modern and chic interiors, enjoying mouthwatering bites and succulent drinks. Regarded as a restaurant that serves modern American cuisine, Atria features decadent Italian meals on the menu. Don’t miss trying the Caramelle, which is a candy-shaped pasta that comes with caramelized onions, blackberry jam, and parmesan broth. This downtown Flagstaff staple offers an extensive selection of cocktails, scotch, whiskey, and wine. Take a seat at the chef’s counter and watch an artistic finesse being applied to each dish. 

Must-Have Dish: Foodies will enjoy completing a meal with the creamy gelato of the day, or Atria’s Ferrero Rocher, experiencing a burst of hazelnut mousse with milk chocolate creme. 

Brix Restaurant and Wine Bar

413 N San Francisco Street

Looking for a new date night spot? Brix Restaurant and Wine Bar features an intimate and cozy space that’s illuminated by warm lighting. While known as a contemporary American dining spot, you’ll find delectable bites such as bolognese, plantain gnocchi and charcuterie boards. Pair your dish with a Tuscan or Sicilian red wine, transporting yourself to the bucolic countryside with this dining experience.
Must-Have Dish: Start your dinner with the eggplant appetizer, taking in rich textures from the vegan ricotta, fresh tomatoes, and zesty lemons.

Fat Olives

2308 E Route 66

With Food Network celebrity Guy Fieri’s stamp of approval, it’s easy to find savory pizza and pasta creations at Fat Olives. Specializing in Neapolitan style pizzas, savory pie lovers will relish ingenious toppings such as BBQ chicken and Calabrian chiles. Browse through different bruschetta choices, enjoying the goat cheese-centered board or the bacon and marmalade combination. Save room for dessert with espresso-drizzled ice cream or a creme brulee cheesecake. 

Must-Have Dish: Enjoy fresh ingredients with the caprese sandwich, experiencing a harmony of seasonings from the pesto, arugula, and lemon balsamic vinaigrette. 

Cafe Stella

7 E Aspen Avenue

Garlic bread, spaghetti with meatballs, and chicken alfredo are some of the comforting foods at Cafe Stella. Based in downtown Flagstaff, this casual eatery offers an outdoor seating area that exudes an inviting ambience. Indulge in brunch delights such as the breakfast bruschetta toast or the grilled cheese and fig sandwich. Foodies with a sweet tooth will enjoy the cannoli-infused French toast or the blueberry pancakes with a zesty lemon sauce. 

Must-Have Dish: Taste flavorsome bites of Scafetti’s Pasta, taking in the slowly simmered tomato sauce that’s poured over handmade penne and coated with cuts of pork chop and garlic bread.

With local-favorite Italian dining spots in the area, you’ll find new brunch, lunch, and dinner options that will step up your daily “rotini.” Looking for more? Discover more scrumptious meals and drinks with Flagstaff’s top-rated restaurants.